Why do you boast of evil, you mighty man?
Why do you boast all day long, you who are a disgrace in the eyes of God?
Your tongue plots destruction; it is like a sharpened razor, you who practice deceit.
You love evil rather than good, falsehood rather than speaking the truth.
You love every harmful word, O you deceitful tongue!
Surely God will bring you down to everlasting ruin:
He will snatch you up and tear you from your tent; he will uproot you from the land of the living.
The righteous will see and fear; they will laugh at him, saying,
"Here now is the man who did not make God his stronghold
but trusted in his great wealth and grew strong by destroying others!"
But I am like an olive tree flourishing in the house of God;
I trust in God's unfailing love forever and ever.
I will praise you forever for what you have done;
In your name I will hope, for your name is good.
I will praise you in the presence of your saints.
-- Psalm 52: 1-9 (NIV)
One of the truly ambivalent benefits of a serious Christian faith is its answer to the problem of suffering, which is the source of both amazing comfort and bitter questions and recriminations against God. A religion that claims an absolutely good, all-powerful, and personal being as its raison d'etre has a lot to answer for when things go wrong, after all. When we are suffering -- physically, emotionally, or spiritually -- Christian doctrine tells us that there is an omnipotent, loving God there for us. That is a very consoling thought. The King of the universe, the Author of time and space and everything that we call "reality" is personally concerned, and personally moved, by all of our individual pains? Well, that makes it easier to bear up under them. But then, if God is so powerful and He cares so much, why doesn't He help? Why doesn't He fix the situation? Or, even better, why didn't He make it so that we never had to deal with it in the first place? Wouldn't that be more loving? Every serious person of faith has to answer these questions at some point. For me, that point came on November 5, 1995.
I was sixteen and in my sophomore year at Central Catholic High School. Freshman year had been pretty typical: I made some friends; I made some mistakes; I had fun. Sophomore year promised to be more fun with (hopefully) fewer mistakes. I had a car now -- a beat-up '85 Dodge Aries that I'd bought off my cousin -- and that was a passport to a lot of new things for my friends and me. And my little brother, Jeffrey, was finally out of the hospital. Now my family and I could relax a little more.
Jeffrey had gone into the hospital for exploratory neurosurgery. He had epilepsy, and his seizures had become very intense and violent lately. He'd gone to Children's Hospital in Boston to see if the parts of his brain that caused his seizures could be safely removed. Something went wrong during the surgery, however. (To this day, we don't know what actually happened.) Jeffrey went into septic shock -- a condition where the body responds as if it has a massive, system-wide infection. That response usually kills the patient. (During a normal infection, the blood vessels near the source of the infection dilate to allow white blood cells to leak into the surrounding tissue to fight it. In septic shock, or sepsis, this happens throughout the entire body. The body swells up to two or three times its normal size, the lungs become sodden and useless, and the organs can't get enough oxygen because there isn't enough blood to bring it to them.) Death from sepsis is usually quick and painful. Jeffrey was given a 3% chance to live.
Fortunately, however, he was at Boston Children's Hospital, one of the two or three best hospitals for children in the world. They had several experimental devices and machines to keep him alive, and the medical staff was second to none. Jeffrey beat the odds and recovered. He spent a month in the ICU and another month in a rehab facility to fully regain his motor skills before he came home in early October. We were so relieved. We knew (well, not my father, who was an atheist -- by my mother and I knew) that God had smiled on us. We knew we'd dodged a bullet and the worst was over.
We were wrong.
November 5 was a Sunday. I remember that because we were supposed to go to church. Jeffrey usually got up early, but sometimes he didn't and we'd have to wake him up. He hadn't gotten up in time, so my mother went in to wake him up. I was laying in bed, enjoying those last few minutes of rest where you're not sleeping but you feel absolutely no obligation to get up. My mother's scream after she entered Jeffrey's room did nothing to change my attitude.
That may sound calloused, but you need to understand -- my mother, good Italian that she is, tends towards the melodramatic. She screams when she drops a pot on the floor (even if it's empty). She screams if she's riding in a car with my father or me and we get closer than the requisite two car lengths she deems an appropriate following distance. She screams for a lot of reasons, few of which were worth rousing myself from the blissful post-slumber rest I was enjoying that morning. Then I heard her call my father.
"Howard! Get in here!"
Now, this didn't necessarily indicate a real problem, either, but it seemed to warrant a little more attention, which I dutifully gave it. Maybe Jeffrey had ripped up his sheets or taken all his clothes out of his drawers -- things he'd been known to do before.
Then I heard my father's voice.
"Oh no! Jeffrey!"
My father's voice, like my own, is not as well equipped for expressing the full range of human emotions as are those of other people (such as my mother or brother, Jon), so it can be hard sometimes to tell what we're feeling without seeing our faces. This was certainly not one of those times. I don't think I can properly express the shock, grief, and despair that I heard in my father's voice at that moment. All I can say is that I've never heard him speak in that tone or with that kind of expression before or since. And I knew that something was very, very wrong.
I jumped out of bed and walked quickly down the twenty-foot hallway between our rooms. And I saw what had made my mother scream. There in his bed lay Jeffrey, cold and blue, a peaceful expression on his face. He'd been dead for hours.
The next several hours were pretty surreal. I remember my father dragging Jeffrey's body (or "Jeffrey" as I preferred to think of it at the time) off the bed and rapidly administering CPR. I remember thick, black blood oozing out of Jeffrey's nose as my father pushed down on his chest, repeatedly trying to force life back into his body. My good friend, John, had slept over the night before, and he called the paramedics. (John had shit luck, sleeping over that night. It's a good thing he did, since I don't think anyone in my family was in a state to speak as calmly to the paramedics as he did. But that was the first time he'd ever experienced one of Jeffrey's frequent medical emergencies, and it was the worst one he could have seen. Jeffrey regularly suffered full-on grand mal seizures, some of which had required hospitalization. Another good friend of mine, Dave, had had the bad luck of sleeping over on a few such occasions, so he would have been a little more familiar with the whole scenario. John, alas, was not.)
The paramedics quickly removed Jeffrey and rushed him to the hospital. One medic stayed behind (I forget why; I only remember talking with him after his colleagues had left) and I asked him if he thought my brother would live. It's obvious now that he knew Jeffrey was dead and he also knew that I didn't want to believe that, so he just told me that he wasn't sure, but that the congealed black blood leaking from Jeffrey's nose wasn't a good sign. The only words of his that registered with me were "I'm not sure," though. I rode with my family to the hospital, clinging desperately to the futile hope that Jeffrey might beat the odds again and live.
C.S. Lewis, in A Grief Observed, compared his confidence in the goodness and providence of God after his wife's death to a mountain climber's confidence in his rope once he as real need of it. It's one thing to say that your rope is strong enough to hold your weight; it's quite another to put all your weight onto it when it's the only thing keeping you from falling hundreds of feet to your death. When that happens, you find out whether you really trust the strength of your rope. Like Lewis, I realized that I didn't really believe my rope was as strong as I'd thought I did. I learned how dangerously easy it is to talk about how good God is when you're not suffering very much. When nothing in your life's gone to shit, the idea that God is in control and has a plan that includes your life makes a lot of sense.
When something in your life goes wrong, however -- really, terribly wrong -- you finally grasp the awful weight behind those simple words: "I believe in God the Father almighty, maker of heaven and earth." I believe in this God? But there must be some mistake. This God just let my brother die. Surely the "maker of heaven and earth" could have done something, couldn't He?
We had so many people wanting to share our grief. Jeffrey was very well-liked in the community, which added to the outpouring of attention that usually follows the sudden death of an 11-year old boy in a town as safe as Salem, New Hampshire was. People from church were the worst. Not that they were obnoxious or self-righteous. Far from it. They were some of the most gracious, wonderful, and helpful people who came to us. But many of them kept saying that God had "a plan" and that I just had to trust him. Didn't they know that I knew that? But what kind of fucked up plan doesn't make a place for a perfectly innocent boy whose family had thought he was lost and had just gotten used to the wonderful idea of having him back?
Or, at least, those were my silent thoughts. To others I talked about how I knew that God had a plan and I fully trusted Him. It was bullshit, of course, but I felt like that was what I should say. I didn't share my real thoughts with anyone, even to God in prayer. (How impertinent to speak to God like that!) I found it hard to pray without cursing at Him or blaming him, though, so I didn't pray much. This was especially tough for me, however, because my prayers had been my biggest source of sustenance during Jeffrey's ordeal in the hospital. It was the only way I'd managed to not dissolve into a frantic, raging, helpless mess as I watched his body deteriorate into a distended, swollen, unrecognizable thing in the hospital. Without my prayers, I began to feel my bitterness and hopelessness rise up to engulf me. So I went downstairs to my private studying area in the basement and I did what I'd heard of other people doing in similar situations (and had mocked them for doing it): I opened my bible to a random passage and began to read. As it happened, the passage I'd opened to was psalm 52.
Psalm 52 is an imprecatory psalm. It's a prayer asking God to curse and kill someone. It's attributed to King David, and is one of the few psalms with a specific narrative reference: "Against Doeg, the Edomite." As the story goes, David, the secretly anointed heir to the throne of Israel, was being hunted by the deranged King Saul. Saul had once been David's greatest benefactor, but had become increasingly paranoid as David's war exploits made him the most popular man in the kingdom. Although David repeatedly pledged his loyalty to Saul, the king tried to kill him and David was forced to flee.
He fled so quickly, in fact, that he took no food or weapons with him. The first place he ran to was Nob, a village of priests whom he asked for food and a weapon. He lied when asked about his purpose, saying he was on a top-secret mission for the king. Against their better judgment, the priests gave David the food and weapon he needed and he went on his way. Doeg, one of the priests' assistants, realized David was lying and ran off to inform Saul, who rushed to Nob with his personal retinue to catch David. He was furious when he learned that David had escaped, and ordered the priests killed for conspiring against him. The only man willing to carry out his order, however, was Doeg, who dutifully murdered 85 priests. Abiathar, son of the head priest, escaped, however, and told David about what had happened. David, consumed with grief and anger at his role in the deaths of the priests, vowed vengeance against Doeg and composed a cursing prayer to God (psalm 52) to kill him.
That's the story behind psalm 52. Not a very likely source of comfort or inspiration, but it provided me with both. I felt a tremendous sense of relief and release that I hadn't realized I needed so badly. I realized at that moment that it was okay to be angry with God. He's big enough to take it. I'd been treating Him the way that my hagwon owner tells me to treat certain spoiled bratty students who aren't used to being disciplined at home. ("Don't yell at Him. He's sensitive.") But what good is a God you can't yell at? "What is this? What are you doing? Why have you hurt me this badly?" Good questions, all. "Why the fuck is this happening to me?" Even better. Rage, as the Croatian theologian, Miroslav Volf, says in his excellent book on Christianity and conflict, Exclusion and Embrace, belongs before God. If I have a problem with something that is not at all in my or anyone else's control, I need to take my questions to the source, just like an angry customer with car troubles on the phone wanting to talk with "Mr. Toyota." If I don't do that, if I feel like I can't do it or like such questions are impertinent, what does that say about what I believe?
So I let myself get angry. Over the next several weeks I yelled and questioned. Above all, I asked why. Why did this happen? What did Jeffrey do, what did we do, to deserve this? How could this be justified? And in the end, I felt the razor sharpness of the double-edged sword of faith: at some point, you have to believe. That's the nature of the game. There is a lot of room for discussion and reasoning, but at a certain point the whole thing is about trust in a person. The absurd image that came into my mind was from the film Aladdin, where Aladdin, before helping the princess onto his flying carpet, asks her, "Do you trust me?" Corny, to be sure, but it cuts to the heart of the issue. If she doesn't trust him, there's no magic ride -- the journey ends right there. If I don't trust God, there's no journey of faith -- no magic, no life. It all ends. That was the question I felt myself being asked: "Do you trust me?" Even in my anger and hurt and confusion over Jeffrey's death, even without all my questions answered, I realized that my answer was "Yes."
It reminded me a little bit of God's answers to Job at the end of the book of Job. He never actually tells Job what he'd spent 30-odd chapters demanding to know, which was why he'd suffered so much when he'd done nothing wrong. Instead God essentially says, "I'm God and you're not. I know why this happened to you, and I'm in control. Even if I don't tell you why it happened, do you trust me to know what's best?" Job did. I realized that I had to, too. I needed to emulate David's attitude in psalm 52, not only in how he began his prayer, but also in how he ended it: I trust in God's unfailing love forever and ever ... in your name I will hope, for your name is good.